Showing posts with label health reform bill. Show all posts
Showing posts with label health reform bill. Show all posts

Thursday, August 2, 2012

Health Care Reform: Let's Not Wait and See


A March Wall Street Journal Article, “Health-Care Law’s Many Unknown Side Effects,” quotes Paul Keckley, the head of the Deloitte Center for Health Solutions, as saying, “If my competitor drops benefits, I’d want to be out the door just behind them.”

Would your clients agree? Where do they stand with changes that health care reform will bring? Are they planning to make changes once you let them know what other companies are doing, post factum? Are they approaching health reform by watching their competitors? Monkey see, monkey do?

We’ve been stewing ever since we read that March article, which closed with a completely unhelpful warning:
“Beware the facile, confident prediction about what the health-care law will yield. Nobody really knows.”
That line goes against everything we believe about competitive strategy. The health care law has significantly altered the structures and incentives which influence employer benefit plans. The primary tools of reform – where people get their coverage and how much money the federal government subsidizes – are going to be with us for the long haul. As one of your clients recently commented, “I cannot be 100% certain where the cost of cotton is going to be in twelve months either, but it doesn’t keep me from critically looking at different cost models and determining how our strategy should change.” 

The macro trends which have affected employer plans over the past 10 years (excessive inflation, changing tax policy, and changing importance of alternative markets) were with us before health care reform and will be with us regardless of the outcome of the election. Doug Elmendorf of the Congressional Budget Office stated, as he testified before Congress in March 2011, “Many of the effects of the legislation may not be felt for several years, because it will take time for workers and employers to recognize and to adapt to the new incentives.”

Our argument is that leading employers will not be the last to know. If they are, they will no longer be leading employers. We believe that health care reform provides the single greatest opportunity in our lifetime for businesses to rethink how they allocate compensation toward benefits. Leading brokers and consultants are talking to their clients (and prospects) about how they can turn benefits into a competitive advantage, instead of a competitive threat. Cost containment and risk management strategies are still important, but understanding the underlying strategic levers that have been highlighted in the latest reforms provides “real” differentiation. 

So do what we’re doing: counter the “facile, confident predictions” with the arduous but profound work of scenario-based modeling. Get strategic plans in place for each of your clients, because our argument is true for you, too: leading consultants will not be the last to respond to health care reform, and if they are, they will no longer be leading consultants.

Eric Helman



This article was first featured in the June 5th edition of our e-newsletter, Directions. If you'd like to receive that weekly email, contact directions@continuoushealth.com. (Your email will never be shared, sold, or otherwise distributed, and you will receive only the type of content for which you sign up.)

Follow ContinuousHealth on LinkedIn or on Twitter @chealthupdate for interesting articles, industry insight, and a first look at new products and services





Tuesday, June 19, 2012

The Indexing Implications of the 2012 Federal Poverty Level Guidelines

A little-discussed portion of PPACA is the indexing of the affordability measurement. Under PPACA, for an employer’s plan to be affordable, the employee cost of the single coverage cannot exceed 9.5% of an employee’s household income (AGHI). In the initial years following 2014, this percentage will be adjusted to reflect the excess of the rate of premium growth over income growth for the prior year as determined by the Secretary of Health and Human Services.

On January 26, 2012, the Department of Health and Human Services published the 2012 Federal Poverty Guidelines (FPL). At that time, the single guideline rose to $11,170, which is up 2.57% over the 2011 single guideline.  That’s a 464.1% growth in the rate of change.

This could have profound ramifications for the indexing of the 9.5% affordability threshold.

As you advise your clients on plan strategy, you may be able to look to the FPL growth as an indicator of income growth. The FPL is a simplified version of the federal poverty thresholds set by the Census Bureau and is used mainly for administrative purposes, such as determining financial eligibility for subsidies in the State Insurance Exchanges. The poverty thresholds set by the Census Bureau act as the starting point for the FPL calculation, with adjustments made based on the prior year’s Consumer Price Index for Urban Consumers (CPI-U).

On January 25, 2012 the Federal Reserve issued a release stating a long term goal of 2% inflation annually, “as measured by the annual change in the price index for personal consumption expenditures” (the CPI-U). In 2010 and 2011 the FPL increased 0% and 0.55% respectively. The recent increase of 2.57% more closely aligns with the Fed’s stated inflation goal.

Regardless, the cost of insurance is increasing at a faster rate than income. In the absence of indexing, more individuals would become eligible for subsidies on the exchange every year.  That, in turn, would cause stress on the viability of the exchanges. With the provision in place, as income growth increases more slowly than premium cost, the affordability percentage will adjust to reflect the excess.

The Supreme Court will issue rulings soon. Regardless of the outcome, it's vital that we understand the consequences and the details of this legislation, and how it may affect your clients. We will continue to work hard to lead the way through PPACA, including the indexing of the affordability measurement.

Jennifer Riley, PHR
CHROME Consultant
www.continuoushealth.com





This article was first featured in the March 27th edition of our e-newsletter, Directions. If you'd like to receive that weekly email, contact directions@continuoushealth.com. (Your email will never be shared, sold, or otherwise distributed, and you will receive only the type of content for which you sign up.)

Follow ContinuousHealth on LinkedIn or on Twitter @chealthupdate for interesting articles, industry insight, and a first look at new products and services.

Tuesday, June 5, 2012

Client Quote


“For the first time ever, I understand what the future holds for health care, and it’s not what I thought. There might be other reasons that I won’t want to grow by 120 units next year, but now that I have this data, health care reform isn’t one of them.”

CEO of a major children’s apparel company, after undergoing a CHROME Compass analysis

Tuesday, May 29, 2012

The C-Suite Engaging HR

In the fall, our firm was approached by a national CEO organization to write an article for CEOs on confronting the rising costs of health care. This group had heard overwhelming feedback from their C-suite members wanting help reducing costs for their health care plans.

Health care reform is already having consequences beyond plan reorganization. PPACA is transforming the landscape of compensation, and, as a result, is inciting action in the leadership that had previously left health care to human resources. The C-suite, and particularly the CFO, brings unique abilities to the dialogue on benefits that can direct a company toward success. It is critical that management, both functional and executive, understands the implications of health care reform in 2014 and beyond.

Increased collaboration between Finance and Human Resources

The number one issue facing businesses today is ambiguity about the future around health care. Ambiguity in changing regulatory guidelines and rising costs causes executives to feel uncertainty about growing their businesses. Business Finance Magazine, in the recent article, “Bridging the CFO-HR Divide,” by Trent Beekman, notes that the average company diverts 1/3 of its finances towards human capital, including benefits. CFOs should be familiar with such a significant portion of company cost.

As health care costs rise year over year, CFOs are recognizing their fiscal responsibility to research the effects of PPACA on their companies. C-level executives (who may have traditionally only stepped in once a year to review rising plan rates) are engaging in the health care discussion. They’re finding that even after necessary cost shifting to employees, changing plans and reducing benefits, health care costs are higher than ever, and they want answers on how to combat this.

One of the answers is coming in the form of changing total compensation programs. Despite rising health care costs, benefits offering must remain competitive in order to retain high-value employees. Compensation strategy must be created with health care reform tax incentives and mandates in mind, and, to quote Beekman, “It will require an all-hands-on-deck mentality.”

Understanding the options

The implications of PPACA will be different for every company. PPACA is transforming the marketplace, both in benefits strategy and in employee opinion of benefits. There are myriad options to best set up a plan strategy for 2014 and beyond, while at the same time offering great coverage to retain top talent. For a company to stay competitive in the years to come, it is crucial that it fully comprehends these options at their deepest level. Finance executives may be more receptive than their HR counterparts to new benefit approaches that take advantage of new structures and incentives created by health care reform. The Business Finance Magazine article points out:

“Historically, CEOs and presidents have made all decisions on human capital expenditures [such as health care], and while they often consult HR as part of that process, more often than not, CFOs are kept out of the loop. Giving CFOs a greater presence and voice in the process could help ensure that such important decisions are more fully vetted.”

Benefits plans are like any other aspect of the business: someone needs to be steering the ship to make sure it goes the right direction. My dad always said, “If the boat misses the harbor, rarely is it the harbor’s fault.” Benefits planning requires more than just setting a budget at the beginning of the year and relying on a human resources team to determine the specifics. The C-Suite has plans for managing every other aspect of the business—a strategic road map is necessary for benefits, too.

Remaining at the forefront

Our company works with senior executives every day to help them optimize their investments in employee benefits. In doing so, we see that, across industries, regions and business sizes, business leaders don’t have the most basic working knowledge about the new structures and incentives embedded in health care reform. Everything else is inconsequential until executives truly understand the implications of health care reform.

As we have been saying for several months, we believe health care reform is the single greatest opportunity in our lifetime to get employers to think differently about how they allocate compensation to benefit programs. The entity (whether a consultant or a carrier) that helps the C-suite with a health care reform response plan will have an excellent opportunity to prescribe a package of products and services to better meet the employer's needs (and escape the potential “trap” of fighting over the scraps left behind after major medical decisions are made).

Now is the time for employers to recognize and implement changes that will set them apart from their competition. The Towers article points out that "savvy organizations need to act now to responsibly assess the business implications, model different scenarios and consider the impact of each reform option on their entire reward program." Leading employers will not be the last to figure out the implications of health care reform. If they are, they will no longer be leading employers.

The CHROME Compass is the leading platform to facilitate this response plan. Certified CHROME Consultants are in the lead position to take advantage of the opportunities created by health care reform. But, as my Dad always says, “Eventually, even the dummies will figure it out.” There is a window of opportunity here. Let’s not miss it!


Eric Helman
CEO and Founder
ContinuousHealth
www.continuoushealth.com


This article was first featured in the March 13th edition of our e-newsletter, Directions. If you'd like to receive that weekly email, contact directions@continuoushealth.com. (Your email will never be shared, sold, or otherwise distributed, and you will receive only the type of content for which you sign up.)

Follow ContinuousHealth on LinkedIn or on Twitter @chealthupdate for interesting articles, industry insight, and a first look at new products and services.

Tuesday, July 26, 2011

What the McKinsey Report on Health Care Really Reveals

Originally published at Executive Street, a Vistage International blog.

Unless you were living under a rock this summer, you probably know that McKinsey & Company published a report titled “How US health care reform will affect employee benefits.” Amongst other findings, the study claims that 30% of employers polled plan to cut their group health care plans.

This caused a stir throughout the political arena, as Republicans cited the report as evidence of the negative consequences of Health Care Reform, and Democrats blasted McKinsey for not releasing their methodology. The real issue lies deeper, and is related to a topic about which I wrote previously on the Vistage blog, Executive Street. 

The Real Revelation
A June 24th, 2011 editorial in the Wall Street Journal got me thinking about the root issue with the McKinsey report and most other media buzz about Health Care Reform. The editorial claims, “The furor says less about McKinsey than about the politically damaging reality of the new law.”  I’d go a different route.  I think the furor over the report reveals that across the board, decision makers don’t know anything (or at least enough) about Health Care Reform.

Upon release of the methodology, expert critics of the findings say that the survey was push polling, feeding questions to executives so as to cause them to give the right answer. Conversely, a Forbes blogger and many others feel that the survey was rigorous, prepared by a creditable research company. 

A Distraction, Not a Solution
Talking about “Shutting up McKinsey” (as the Wall Street Journal editorial stated) is, like so many things in the discussion about health care reform, a distraction. Whether or not the McKinsey results will be an accurate prediction of executive behavior, or if the survey did or did not meet the standards for academic rigor, might be newsworthy, but they miss the most important point. It is inconsequential until executives truly understand the implications of health care reform.

Our company works with senior executives every day to help them optimize their investments in employee benefits.  In doing so, we see that, across industries, regions and sizes of business, business leaders don’t have the most basic working knowledge about the new structures and incentives embedded in health care reform—and many don’t want to, as we mentioned in our last Vistage post when we referenced a survey that the WSJ’s CFO blog covered in May. That Journal article stated, “Of the 151 CFOs and executives of mid-sized companies… only 1 in 5 said they have actually given a great deal of thought to the health-care overhaul.” The backlash on the McKinsey report shows that statistic is probably accurate nationwide.

It is critical that executives do understand the implications of Health Care Reform in 2014 and beyond.  To quote the last paragraph of the now infamous McKinsey report:
Whether your company is poised to shift from employer-sponsored insurance or will continue to offer the same benefit package it does now, health care reform will change the economics of your workforce and benefits, as well as how your employees value coverage. Understanding these changes at a granular level will enable your company to gain or defend a competitive advantage in the increasingly dynamic market for talent [emphasis is mine].

Leading beyond 2014
It is irrelevant if McKinsey did or did not lead executives to a particular answer.  The fact remains that if you can be led, you don’t know enough.  If you want to know how your business (and your employees) will be impacted by health care reform, get some help. As Doug Elmendorf of the Congressional Budget Office testified before Congress on March 30, 2011, “Moreover, many of the effects of the legislation may not be felt for several years because it will take time for workers and employers to recognize and to adapt to the new incentives.” Leading employers will not be the last to know. If they are, they will no longer be leading employers.

Thanks for reading,
Eric


For more information about Health Care Reform or Dependent Eligibility Verification Audits, follow ContinuousHealth and Vistage member Eric Helman, CEO of ContinuousHealth, at @CHealthUpdate or visit www.continuoushealth.com. ContinuousHealth is an independent organization located in Atlanta Georgia that uses proprietary technology to help employers optimize their investments in employee benefits programs.  ContinuousHealth has performed over 250 Dependent Eligibility Verification projects. ContinuousHealth distributes its products through an exclusive network of certified Brokers and Consultants. 

Executive Street Featured Author

Tuesday, July 19, 2011

Early Results are In: HCR may increase the Number of Ineligible Dependents

Originally published at Executive Street, a Vistage International blog.
While Health Care Reform is currently a much-discussed item in the media, the Wall Street Journal recently reported that the majority of CFOs are not considering the repercussions for their companies. The following study proves the fiscal responsibility for corporate leadership to research the effects of the Patient Protection and Affordable Care Act (PPACA) on their health care plans.

Ineligible Dependents:  Previously 5-12% of Dependents on Group Health Care Plans
Many experts believe that the number of ineligible dependents on a company’s health care plan will decrease as the mandates of the PPACA take effect. Nationwide, prior to PPACA, between 5-12% of group plan participants were typically found to be ineligible. The early results are in for a study showing that wider eligibility criteria may, in fact, directly correlate to higher percentages of ineligible dependents. 

Reform guidelines now require that adult children up to the age of 26 be eligible for coverage on their parents’ group health care plans, regardless of marital or employment status.* Many employers assume that this will significantly increase their enrollment body, and recent news reports confirm.  The enrollment of this age group is even higher than expected, as many as 600,000 new dependents in the first year alone.

Relatedly, many employers believe that investigating ineligibles is no longer necessary. Full-time student verification of that age group was standard practice with most group health care providers, and with this demographic now under mandated coverage, why check at all?

The Effects of Health Care Reform
Statistics gathered from recently conducted dependent eligibility verification audits show the need still exists and is, in fact, greater than ever. Projects completed since the implementation of Health Care Reform guidelines show nearly double the number of ineligible dependents. The average number of ineligible dependents identified on group coverage has risen from 8% to over 15%. 

The same ineligible dependents who existed prior to 9/23/10, excepting non-students, are still attempting to gain coverage from group plans. Dependents typically found who are not eligible for most plans include:
Ø  former spouses,
Ø  non-spouses,
Ø  former stepchildren,
Ø  grandchildren,
Ø  grandchildren over the age of 18 who are not enrolled in school,
Ø  non-child blood relatives and
Ø  non-eligible dependents declared on tax returns. 
Additionally, Health Care Reform has created new potentially ineligible dependent types, namely spouses and adult children who have coverage on other plans.

Prior to Reform, approximately 24% of ineligible dependents fell into the age range of 19-26. Of that 24%, half are unable to prove relationship. Thus, only 12% of typical ineligible dependents were previously non-students and are likely to qualify for coverage as a result of the change in age requirements. To put that into perspective, if a hypothetical employer covers 1,250 dependents and falls in the middle ground of 8% ineligible, 100 dependents would exit the plan. Health Care Reform guidelines for adult children now make 12 of those eligible. The other 88 remain ineligible and underscore the importance of continuing to verify dependent eligibility in a post-Health Care Reform nation. 

While the wider eligibility guidelines of PPACA do result in more dependents on a plan, the instance of and the exposure risk associated with ineligible dependents has not decreased. Rather, early results show that Health Care Reform directly correlates with higher percentages of ineligible dependents and, thus, an increased fiscal responsibility for CEOs and CFOs to recognize and eliminate fraud.

Case Study Results from Recent Dependent Eligibility Verification Audits:

Client A
Client B
Client C
Client D
Industry
Transportation / Manufacturing
National Retail Chain
Automotive Manufacturing
Hospital Management System - 15 hospitals
# Dependents
350
11,000+
3,500
17,000+
Grandfathered or Non-Grandfathered
Non-grandfathered
Grandfathered: 
Adult Children eligible for own employers’ plan were ineligible
Non-grandfathered
TBD;
2 Hospitals under “RomneyCare”
First Plan Renewal
9/1/2011, but implemented on 9/1/2010;
Age 26 compliant for 4 months at verification start
2/1/2011;
started verifying for HCR in mid-January
2/2011;
started verifying for HCR in mid-February
7/1/2011
Results
14.5% of dependents were ineligible, far higher than leadership expected
·  20% increase in Open Enrollment numbers

·  Original project in 2009-2010 found 16.56% of 11,175 dependents were ineligible

·  First 4 months of PPACA showed that 30.57% of the 1,796 newly enrolled were ineligible
·  Original DEVA found 10.55% of enrolled were ineligible

·  Post-HCR DEVA found 27.91% of new enrollees were ineligible

·  Initial project:  10.1% ineligibles

·  2 Hospitals excluded from initial verification because they were under RomneyCare. These did a DEVA after seeing other 13 hospitals’ results

·  Results were comparable: RomneyCare project:  6.34% ineligibles in one and 9.64% in the other
Financial Exposure Reduction
Over $184,960
·  Original project:  $4,995,000
·  First 4 months of PPACA: $1,482,300
·  Original project:  $1,114,345
·  First 4 months of PPACA: $1,500,442
Total savings:  $4,165,246

A White Paper detailing final results will be available after all members of the study have been subject to PPACA regulations for six months or more. For more information about Health Care Reform or Dependent Eligibility Verification Audits, reach out to Vistage member Eric Helman, CEO of ContinuousHealth, at ehelman@continuoushealth.com, or visit www.continuoushealth.com. ContinuousHealth is an independent organization located in Atlanta Georgia that uses proprietary technology to help employers optimize their investments in employee benefits programs.  ContinuousHealth has performed over 250 Dependent Eligibility Verification projects. ContinuousHealth distributes its products through an exclusive network of certified Brokers and Consultants.