Showing posts with label CFO. Show all posts
Showing posts with label CFO. Show all posts

Thursday, August 16, 2012

Feds Can’t Force Medicaid Expansion – Good or Bad News for Employers?

As many of you know, we try our best to be apolitical when it comes to interpretation of various legal and regulatory updates. There are plenty of other outlets for that. We are focused on the impact on employers and their employees. So when the most significant new development created by the SCOTUS decision centers around Medicaid expansion, we immediately analyzed the potential impact on employers.  Let’s walk through the ruling and the potential outcomes and what it means to you and your clients.

While I was personally surprised with the SCOTUS outcome (and impressed by the nuanced maneuvering around the Commerce Clause issue), I want to focus on the “new” stuff we must now consider because of the ruling. Specifically, will states opt in to the expanded definition of Medicaid? And if they don’t, how will employers in those states be impacted?
In a bit of a surprise, the majority opinion, authored by Chief Justice Roberts, found the Medicaid expansion to be constitutional in part and unconstitutional in part. The opinion upheld Congress’s right to stipulate the conditions under which federal funds are used by states; however, the opinion also found the threat of a state losing all of its existing Medicaid funding if it elected not to participate in the expansion to be unduly coercive. Consequently, the decision maintains the expansion of Medicaid provided for under PPACA as optional to all states, by prohibiting the Secretary of Health and Human Services from discontinuing funds for existing Medicaid programs for those states that choose not to participate in the expansion.

So, what does this mean?

Well, this means that the twenty-six states that brought suit gained a partial victory: they won’t lose any existing funding if they choose not to participate in the expansion. Elected officials for many states have already issued statements regarding the ruling. The governor of Washington, one of the 26 plaintiffs that brought suit, has indicated that her state most likely will participate.

This, however, does not necessarily mean that all twenty-six will choose to participate. Lieutenant Governor Tate Reeves has expressed serious doubt about Mississippi’s likelihood of opting to expand Medicaid. "An expanded Medicaid program would add almost 400,000 new enrollees and cost the state an estimated $1.7 billion over the next ten years. Mississippi taxpayers simply cannot afford that cost, so our state is not inclined to drastically expand Medicaid.” Nebraska Governor Dave Heineman also expressed concerns about the impact the Medicaid expansion would have on other state programs, calling the expansion “unfunded.” As of the date of this newsletter, other participating states, such as Idaho, have not yet released statements regarding the decision. Just yesterday, Rick Scott from Florida said they won’t expand while certain Republican members of the legislature said they would. I guess we are in store for some more wrangling over the next several months.

But back to the point - how will this affect employers?

In states that elect to expand Medicaid eligibility, all individuals with household incomes below 138% of the federal poverty line (FPL) are eligible to receive coverage through Medicaid. When they enroll in this coverage, employers are not penalized.

In states that elect not to expand eligibility, all individuals between 100% and 138% FPL would be eligible for premium tax credits and out-of-pocket subsidies at the Exchange if the employer’s coverage is deemed unacceptable or unaffordable. If an individual receives a tax credit, their applicable employer will be subject to the $3,000 tack-hammer penalty.

So, by not expanding Medicaid eligibility, a state may be increasing the potential liability for their employers. This will especially be true for businesses with lower wage part-time employees such as retail and hospitality.

How will this affect you?

States now find themselves in a tenuous situation where, if they choose not to expand eligibility, the lowest income working adults will not have access to affordable insurance, and employers in that state will potentially be subject to higher penalty. For the first 3 years, the eligibility expansion is 100% federally funded, tapering off to 90% by 2020; however, the federal funding is for coverage only and does not extend to increased administrative costs. The administrative burden of handling the new potentially eligible Medicaid recipients can prove costly, as expressed above by Mississippi Lieutenant Governor Tate Reeves.

In short, while the Supreme Court’s decision provided some clarity around the fate of PPACA, it also raises many questions and increases the likelihood of future changes. We anticipate that most states will develop projections to examine the impact of both expanding and opting out, as either decision carries significant impact. Based on those decisions (*Opportunity Alert*), employers will look to their brokers for guidance and strategy. As you would expect, we have already modified our CHROME Compass platform to model the various scenarios and the impact on employers.  Over the next couple of months we’ll discuss strategy and outcomes in more detail.





This article was first featured in the July 3rd edition of our e-newsletter, Directions. If you'd like to receive that weekly email, contact directions@continuoushealth.com. (Your email will never be shared, sold, or otherwise distributed, and you will receive only the type of content for which you sign up.)

Follow ContinuousHealth on LinkedIn or on Twitter @chealthupdate for interesting articles, industry insight, and a first look at new products and services.


Tuesday, August 14, 2012

The way of business: Adapt or Die

A few months ago, the Wall Street Journal published an article detailing the potential consequences of health care reform. Over the past three years, there’s been a slowdown in spending here, and economists initially thought this may show the effects of health care reform as a cost savings. The Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services just released a study showing that the legislation would, in fact, probably cause an increase in health spending starting in 2014. After that initial peak, the study predicted the rate would drop but still grow at a higher rate than we’ve seen recently. The thing is, we don’t really agree. Read on to see if you think we’re right.

The actual numbers make the reasons for the drop clearer: current spending has averaged about 4% annual growth for the past three years and is predicted to continue for the next two. In 2014, spending is expected to jump to 7.4% annual growth due to the market flood of participants gaining coverage through government-subsidized insurance plans or Medicaid. Health care cost increases would then level off in 2015 to about 6.2% for the next several years.
The increased spending is attributed to an escalation in routine doctors’ visits, prescriptions, and administrative costs. The article does point out that only 0.1% of the growth would be attributed to new portions of the law, and that most of the issue comes from the increased number of people in the market, particularly aging baby boomers.

The thing is, we don’t really agree.
Businesses have always found a way to circumvent any classic logarithmic equation that would result in increased costs.

Currently, benefits are intrinsically linked to compensation, so, to maintain competitive advantage in hiring, companies must offer competitive benefits. But if health spending goes up, then benefits will change in the private sector. The article even hints at this, though it fails to connect to the future effects—it points out that the reduced spending we’re seeing right now is partially because “employers have trimmed insurance since the U.S. first fell into a recession.”
That is the way of business. Adapt or die.

More aging baby boomers on the plan? Try a working spouse policy—either spousal carve out or surcharge would offset some increased costs. Or a dependent verification, which ensures that the employer isn’t paying for the extra costs of ex-spouses or any other ineligible dependents.
Escalation in doctors’ visits? Implement high deductible plans. They turn employees into consumers, giving them awareness of the costs associated with unnecessary visits. Or include telemedicine as an additional offering, driving down urgent care and emergency visits at the same time.

You see our point. Businesses are adaptable, and they will find a way to not have a 7.3% increase. In fact, you’re probably walking your clients and prospects through some cost saving options right now.
What we can all agree on, though, is that the government probably won’t move so fast.




This article was first featured in the June 26th edition of our e-newsletter, Directions. If you'd like to receive that weekly email, contact directions@continuoushealth.com. (Your email will never be shared, sold, or otherwise distributed, and you will receive only the type of content for which you sign up.)

Follow ContinuousHealth on LinkedIn or on Twitter @chealthupdate for interesting articles, industry insight, and a first look at new products and services.



Thursday, August 9, 2012

Dealing with the Effects of PPACA


We think it’s pretty important to stay on the forefront of the research, and we like it even more when the research parallels what we’re finding in our day to day work with your clients. Last week, the International Foundation of Employee Benefit Plans (IFEBP) released results from the third survey in a series dealing with the effects of PPACA on single employer plans. The responding 968 employers were asked questions about the actions they’ve already taken and anticipate taking in the next two years as a result of PPACA. We reviewed the results and would like to share some of our insights.

Eliminating Coverage


A key finding was that only 1% of respondents stated they will definitely not provide coverage to all full-time employees in 2014, with 95.3% at least somewhat likely to continue to offer coverage. This is a dramatic shift from the 30-50% of employers likely to drop coverage reported in the June 2011 McKinsey Quarterly and more consistent with what we’ve seen from the over 600 employers on our CHROME Compass platform.

Doing the footwork


Curiously, employers have shifted their view on offering benefits coverage but many have not conducted an analysis on the impact of health care reform on their organization. The findings in the survey are somewhat conflicting with a reported 47.2% of respondents stating they “have conducted an analysis on how health care reform legislation will impact their health care plan costs,” but only 24.9% of respondents stating they “have modeled the impact of reform on our organization.”

Regardless, even in a best case scenario, slightly more than half of all employers have done nothing to anticipate the impact of health care reform. 

Nearly 70% of respondents expect increased benefits costs in 2012 due to health care reform, and even more interestingly, “those reporting their organizations had analyzed costs are slightly less likely to predict a cost increase”. In other words, slightly more than two thirds of employers surveyed are expecting a cost increase, but those expecting an increase are more likely to have not conducted a cost analysis. Perhaps this is because, in our experience, if employers do the math at a very granular level, they gain insights about health care reform that might actually allow them to lower their health benefits costs. Employers who have not done the analysis are influenced by the political debate instead of the facts as they apply to their particular situation.

Anticipating the Costs


Also consistent with what we have seen, respondents are already making changes to deal with increased costs, either thru increased contributions or plan design changes, and if they haven’t, they are planning to do so in the next two years.

The most popular strategy currently in use is increasing participant premium contributions (23.1% of employers). In the next two years, the most popular strategy employers plan on using is increasing contributions for dependent coverages (20.1%).

Despite the popularity, or perhaps because of it, we do issue a caveat on that strategy alone: PPACA has provided employers with new benchmarks as to what is considered “affordable” contributions. With somewhere between only 24% and 47% of employers having conducted an analysis, some of these employers may be making shifts blind to the impact it will have on their plans in 2014. While their decision to increase contributions may be the correct strategy, if they have not conducted the analysis, they might not fully appreciate the implications in light of the affordability benchmarks of PPACA.

Extending coverage to adult children (up to age 26) was identified as the top cost driver by 38.7% of respondents, more than any other one driver. Three major carriers recently stated that, regardless of the Supreme Court’s decision, they will continue to allow coverage for adult children, putting pressure on employers to continue to offer this popular and costly benefit to their employees.

Employers are also taking other measures to contain costs such as plan audits or analyses, with the most popular tactic being dependent-eligibility audits. Of the employers surveyed, 18.7% had already conducted a dependent audit and 14.7% are planning on conducting one in the next two years. These findings are consistent with the growth in dependent audits we have seen at ContinuousHealth:  100% growth year over year in initial audits, and nearly 200% growth in ongoing audits since PPACA. As we mentioned a few weeks ago, contrary to the pervasive belief that PPACA has decreased the need for dependent audits, we’ve seen average rate of ineligibles grow from 6.5% to 7.99%. Survey results seem to indicate that employers see this continued need as well.

Proactive, not Reactive


Based upon the current law, the major changes established in health care reform will take place in 2014, but employers have to make changes to their benefit plans now as a response to continuing price increases in excess of inflation. For most employers, there are still two open enrollments left before the bulk of the changes become effective. This survey highlights the fact that the majority of employers are making tactical decisions about their benefit plans without informed analysis regarding the single greatest external event to affect employee benefits in our lifetimes.

As Mark Bertolini (CEO of Aetna) said recently in a Wall Street Journal interview, PPACA has provided a catalyst to change the conversation around employee benefits. While not all employers will specifically change their strategies based upon healthcare reform, feedback from our clients leads us to believe enough employers will make adjustments. These adjustments are likely to influence the overall marketplace.  We believe the employers who “sit this one out” will be at a disadvantage as they attempt to align their investment in employee benefits with their recruitment and retention programs.


This article was first featured in the June 19th edition of our e-newsletter, Directions. If you'd like to receive that weekly email, contact directions@continuoushealth.com. (Your email will never be shared, sold, or otherwise distributed, and you will receive only the type of content for which you sign up.)

Follow ContinuousHealth on LinkedIn or on Twitter @chealthupdate for interesting articles, industry insight, and a first look at new products and services.


Thursday, August 2, 2012

Health Care Reform: Let's Not Wait and See


A March Wall Street Journal Article, “Health-Care Law’s Many Unknown Side Effects,” quotes Paul Keckley, the head of the Deloitte Center for Health Solutions, as saying, “If my competitor drops benefits, I’d want to be out the door just behind them.”

Would your clients agree? Where do they stand with changes that health care reform will bring? Are they planning to make changes once you let them know what other companies are doing, post factum? Are they approaching health reform by watching their competitors? Monkey see, monkey do?

We’ve been stewing ever since we read that March article, which closed with a completely unhelpful warning:
“Beware the facile, confident prediction about what the health-care law will yield. Nobody really knows.”
That line goes against everything we believe about competitive strategy. The health care law has significantly altered the structures and incentives which influence employer benefit plans. The primary tools of reform – where people get their coverage and how much money the federal government subsidizes – are going to be with us for the long haul. As one of your clients recently commented, “I cannot be 100% certain where the cost of cotton is going to be in twelve months either, but it doesn’t keep me from critically looking at different cost models and determining how our strategy should change.” 

The macro trends which have affected employer plans over the past 10 years (excessive inflation, changing tax policy, and changing importance of alternative markets) were with us before health care reform and will be with us regardless of the outcome of the election. Doug Elmendorf of the Congressional Budget Office stated, as he testified before Congress in March 2011, “Many of the effects of the legislation may not be felt for several years, because it will take time for workers and employers to recognize and to adapt to the new incentives.”

Our argument is that leading employers will not be the last to know. If they are, they will no longer be leading employers. We believe that health care reform provides the single greatest opportunity in our lifetime for businesses to rethink how they allocate compensation toward benefits. Leading brokers and consultants are talking to their clients (and prospects) about how they can turn benefits into a competitive advantage, instead of a competitive threat. Cost containment and risk management strategies are still important, but understanding the underlying strategic levers that have been highlighted in the latest reforms provides “real” differentiation. 

So do what we’re doing: counter the “facile, confident predictions” with the arduous but profound work of scenario-based modeling. Get strategic plans in place for each of your clients, because our argument is true for you, too: leading consultants will not be the last to respond to health care reform, and if they are, they will no longer be leading consultants.

Eric Helman



This article was first featured in the June 5th edition of our e-newsletter, Directions. If you'd like to receive that weekly email, contact directions@continuoushealth.com. (Your email will never be shared, sold, or otherwise distributed, and you will receive only the type of content for which you sign up.)

Follow ContinuousHealth on LinkedIn or on Twitter @chealthupdate for interesting articles, industry insight, and a first look at new products and services





Tuesday, July 24, 2012

Who can say if PPACA changed benefits for the better?

Employer-sponsored health insurance market has been eroding subtly and gradually over the past decade. Most employers have noticed the downward spiral in their plans, but they’ve been unable to effectively identify or counteract the issues. Changes to the health insurance market have been (and will continue to be) inevitable, regardless of the decision on health care reform. But many of your clients are now modeling one to three year strategies for their plans, using predictive modeling tools like our CHROME Compass.  These tools that were created as a response to health care reform, but they are also revolutionizing the way that employers see compensation.

Health care reform has changed the way everyone thinks about benefits programs… regardless of the decision.  Hear us out, and let us know if you agree.

While many in the employee benefits business are taking a “wait and see” attitude toward the Supreme Court deliberations and inevitable announcement in late June, others are taking a fresh look at their benefits program in light of the new opportunities and incentives created by health care reform. Is this a waste of time or are they gaining valuable insights leading to strategies that may increase their competitive advantages in their total employee rewards program? Won’t the game change entirely if health care reform is overturned?

Employer-sponsored health insurance was eroding long before health care reform


The rising cost of health insurance over the last ten years has significantly changed where people receive their coverage, how much they pay for it, and how much protection the benefit provides. Let’s start with a brief look at where people are receiving their coverage and how this has changed over the past decade. 

From 1999 to 2010, according to information from the U.S. Census, the number of people in the U.S. grew 10.6%. Surprisingly, the number of individuals who accessed health insurance at their employer dropped by 4.7%. Now, before you jump to a conclusion about changing demographics and the aging population, consider that when we look at the same data for the non-elderly (<65) population, we see an overall growth rate of 10.8% but a reduction in employer-sponsored health insurance of 5.7%. While the overall growth rate is within .2%, the reduction in the number of non-elderly individuals who accessed health insurance at their employer is greater by 1%.

Older people are staying on their employer plans longer. This is surprising, especially in light of the significant migration in benefits away from retiree health programs during this same time period.  Unfortunately, the corollary is that younger employees must be leaving their employers’ plans at a disproportionately high rate, accelerating the impact of rising health care costs on employer plans.

The second conclusion you might want to explore is whether the most recent recession and the reduction in employment is a major contributor to this erosion. Here again, the data says otherwise. Using the same period from 1999 to 2010, the Bureau of Labor Statistics reports the number of employed Americans actually grew from 133.5 million to 138.9 million (4.1%). While this obviously did not keep pace with population growth, it was still positive growth and does not explain the sharp reduction in employer-sponsored coverage over this time period.   

So, if people are leaving employer-based coverage, where are they going?

The answer, in terms of percentage growth from highest to lowest, is Medicaid (+78%), military (+51%), uninsured (+32%) and Medicare (+20%).

And remember, this is without health care reform. 

The erosion of the employer sponsored health insurance market has been both subtle and gradual. For this reason, most employers have been unable to effectively identify or counteract this downward spiral in their plans. Changes to the health insurance market have been (and will continue to be) inevitable as long as the growth in cost outpaces overall growth rates.

Enter health care reform.


In the words of Doug Elmendorf from the Congressional Budget Office, “Many of the effects of the legislation may not be felt for several years, because it will take time for workers and employers to recognize and to adapt to the new incentives.” Employers who were drawn to model the impact of the dramatic reform changes are not only better prepared for health care reform, but they have also gained insights into the erosion they have been experiencing over the past ten years. 

Health care reform changes the mandated eligibility requirements in three of the five health insurance markets (Medicare, employer and individual) while at the same time significantly changing the tax structure in all three of these markets. Among other things, health care reform attempts to reduce the number of uninsured people in this country by offering new opportunities and incentives which affect three existing markets. Health care reform mandates expanded eligibility for both Medicaid and the employer markets. The individual market, too, is significantly reformed with the elimination of medical underwriting and, for the first time ever, significant tax subsidies for individual premiums are equal to or greater than those available in the employer market. 

By analyzing the potential impacts of these accelerated market shifts brought on by health care reform, employers are gaining valuable insights into what has been happening to their plans for the past 10 years. Whether health care reform is overturned or not, these employers are leveraging these insights to plot new strategies that are more proactive and intentional – transforming them from victims of health care inflation to strategic players in the allocation of employee compensation.

The light switch


Over 600 employers are now using our proprietary CHROME Compass planning platform to conduct the detailed analysis required to truly understand the intricate interdependencies of alternative insurance markets and tax policy changed by health care reform. In light of the upcoming Supreme Court decision, we asked many of these customers what insights they are gaining from the detailed modeling around health care reform and what value they see in it if heath care reform is overturned by the high court.

The most common responses we received across our diverse group of clients were:

We had never really looked at where all the dollars were going, especially in the area of favorable tax treatment.

We had been feeling the erosion of our benefit plan over the years, but, with this, it was like someone flicked on the light switch and we saw where we are in an entirely new light.

We now know how to ask ourselves, “Is this where we want to be? If not, how do we begin to work ourselves into a new place?”

These employers were only moved to review their benefits program because of the legislation. Once these tools made them aware of the possibilities in overall compensation strategy, though, their benefits programs will never be the same. The light switch is on.







This article was first featured in the May 22nd edition of our e-newsletter, Directions. If you'd like to receive that weekly email, contact directions@continuoushealth.com. (Your email will never be shared, sold, or otherwise distributed, and you will receive only the type of content for which you sign up.)

Follow ContinuousHealth on LinkedIn or on Twitter @chealthupdate for interesting articles, industry insight, and a first look at new products and services.

Thursday, July 19, 2012

A Quiet Revolution

The New York Times published an article Sunday about the slowing of health care inflation over the past two years. Health care costs are down 4% (adjusted for inflation: 3.1%), over the past two years. The reporter interviewed a handful of experts, from Harvard economists to the president of the Commonwealth Fund to the former head of Medicare and Medicaid. All of them said the same thing, best summed up by one expert in particular: ““The most honest thing to say is that, one, the reduction in use is greater than the recession predicts; two, we don’t understand why yet; and, three, you’d be foolhardy to say that we can understand it.”

Well, you can call us foolhardy, because our extensive work with a large number of clients has resulted in a confidence that we understand why health care inflation has slowed over the past few years. Let’s talk this through.

The preamble

Not to be picky, but before going any further, we have to make a comment about the routine (and incorrect) use of the term “health care inflation.” While we are not economists, most of us took a few econ classes in undergrad, and we learned enough to know that “inflation” is a general increase in prices as a result of too much money chasing too few goods. What passes for inflation as it relates to health care is actually increased consumption – in both quantity and through the consumption of higher priced treatments. In fact, many health care prices are actually moderating on a unit cost basis, owing to competitive pressures and patent expirations. People can’t fix what they don’t understand, and using incorrect terminology doesn’t help. We expect better from The New York Times, and we bet you do, too. OK, now that we’ve cleared that up…

After years of health care costs increasing as a percentage of the gross domestic product, 2009 and 2010 showed a significant slowing down of the health care cost curve. In fact, the total national health care spending growth of less than 4% per year is the slowest annual pace in more than fifty years. If it continues to hold steady at 17.9% of the GDP, there is hope for long term fiscal health for both national and household income, but in order to capture that slowing and replicate it year over year, we have to know why it’s happening.

And, according to the New York Times article, experts have no idea why this is happening.

Is it the recession?


Keeping with the zeitgeist of the time, the article first points the blame at the recession. The slowdown did occur during the same time as employer-based insurance options dipped for many Americans due to job loss. The recession may have made Americans more aware of health costs, who cut back on non-urgent care while money was tight. Gail Wilensky, speaker of our “foolhardy” quote, headed Medicare and Medicaid under President George Bush and believes the dip was caused by decreased income and decreased wealth during the recession. She fails to mention, however, that the COBRA subsidy program under ARRA artificially suppressed the number of “uninsured” you would typically expect when jobs are cut. And the fact these people stayed insured should have resulted in less of a drop in consumption than typically found in recessions.
The experts in the article all agreed that mitigation caused by recession would not be surprising or unexpected.

No, it’s not the recession (at least not entirely)


But a lot of the data points to a cause beyond the recession. States that weren’t hit too badly by the recession had some of the most rapid abatement in health care inflation. And some of the slowed spending occurred in market segments that shouldn’t have been recession-sensitive, like those on Medicaid and Medicare.

“The recession just doesn’t account for the numbers we’re seeing,” said David Cutler, a Harvard health economist and former adviser to President Obama. “I think there’s much more going on. If you asked me, ‘How confident are you that this is not just the recession?’ I’d say 75 percent.”

Well, then, is it health care reform?


The president of the Commonwealth Fund, Karen Davis, makes the case that health care reform is the cause: “A lot of the big gains have come from keeping people out of the hospital and the emergency rooms.”

No, it’s not health care reform (at least not entirely)


While a reduction in those big price-tag claims would account for the decreased spending, it’s unlikely that health reform has drastically reduced hospital and emergency room visits at this stage.

As we discussed last week, the high risk pool, PPACA’s interim solution to improve access to health coverage, has low engagement rates, and the uninsured rate has remained steady through 2010. Even for the 18-25 year old age range, the uninsured rate has declined from 28% to about 24% and has now leveled off over 2011.

Additionally, many economists believe costs may go up as tax incentives and new programs come into effect.

Is it… consumerism?

The Times article starts to hint at this option, but it fails to establish a conclusion. The author discusses the growth of high-deductible plans, cited as growth from 3% in 2006 to 13% in 2011, and how those plans impact the way that people think about health care. The author notes, “A broad, bipartisan range of academics, hospital administrators and policy experts has started to wonder if what had seemed impossible might be happening — if doctors and patients have begun to change their behavior in ways that bend the so-called cost curve.”

But we believe there’s no need to wonder. This behavioral change is well documented, from a recent Reuters article about the growth of consumer-direction coverage to the RAND study that shows high deductible plans may reduce spending by as much as 14%.


Our foolhardy proposition

Consumerism, we believe, is the key to the mitigation of health care inflation. As we pointed out earlier, in all other aspects of economics, inflation is a rise in cost of goods, but as it pertains to health care, inflation is a rise in use and engagement. Therefore, increased health care costs are increased use of the goods. Consumerism has everything to do with slowing health care spending.

In all segments, people are becoming more aware of the cost of health care. Insurance plans are becoming less rich, and people are more price-sensitive. That applies even in the Medicare world, as retiree health plans start to disappear.

As patients become consumers, they pay more attention to the market and to the costs of services. A September RAND study shows that patients with consumer-directed health plans not only reduce their costs through initiating health care less frequently, but also by reducing costs after they’ve begun care, sometimes through electing less expensive treatments or medications.

The past few years have seen a dramatic growth in the consumer-directed plans and the awareness of health care costs. With that, people are becoming more aware of their own consumption. Reduced consumption equals mitigated health care inflation.

We like the way Dr. Drew Altman, the president and CEO of the Kaiser Family Foundation, sums up the rise in consumer-directed plans: “Well you know, I think we've been so focused on health reform in Washington, what we have missed is there is a quiet revolution happening in health insurance out in the country.”

So how are you engaging in the quiet revolution? Are you helping your clients implement high deductible plans? And if so, have your clients seen a decline in health care spending? Is it just a coincidence that the “minimum” level of an acceptable employer-provided plan mirrors a high deductible health plan (without HSA contribution)?








This article was first featured in the May 7th edition of our e-newsletter, Directions. If you'd like to receive that weekly email, contact directions@continuoushealth.com. (Your email will never be shared, sold, or otherwise distributed, and you will receive only the type of content for which you sign up.)

Follow ContinuousHealth on LinkedIn or on Twitter @chealthupdate for interesting articles, industry insight, and a first look at new products and services

Tuesday, May 29, 2012

The C-Suite Engaging HR

In the fall, our firm was approached by a national CEO organization to write an article for CEOs on confronting the rising costs of health care. This group had heard overwhelming feedback from their C-suite members wanting help reducing costs for their health care plans.

Health care reform is already having consequences beyond plan reorganization. PPACA is transforming the landscape of compensation, and, as a result, is inciting action in the leadership that had previously left health care to human resources. The C-suite, and particularly the CFO, brings unique abilities to the dialogue on benefits that can direct a company toward success. It is critical that management, both functional and executive, understands the implications of health care reform in 2014 and beyond.

Increased collaboration between Finance and Human Resources

The number one issue facing businesses today is ambiguity about the future around health care. Ambiguity in changing regulatory guidelines and rising costs causes executives to feel uncertainty about growing their businesses. Business Finance Magazine, in the recent article, “Bridging the CFO-HR Divide,” by Trent Beekman, notes that the average company diverts 1/3 of its finances towards human capital, including benefits. CFOs should be familiar with such a significant portion of company cost.

As health care costs rise year over year, CFOs are recognizing their fiscal responsibility to research the effects of PPACA on their companies. C-level executives (who may have traditionally only stepped in once a year to review rising plan rates) are engaging in the health care discussion. They’re finding that even after necessary cost shifting to employees, changing plans and reducing benefits, health care costs are higher than ever, and they want answers on how to combat this.

One of the answers is coming in the form of changing total compensation programs. Despite rising health care costs, benefits offering must remain competitive in order to retain high-value employees. Compensation strategy must be created with health care reform tax incentives and mandates in mind, and, to quote Beekman, “It will require an all-hands-on-deck mentality.”

Understanding the options

The implications of PPACA will be different for every company. PPACA is transforming the marketplace, both in benefits strategy and in employee opinion of benefits. There are myriad options to best set up a plan strategy for 2014 and beyond, while at the same time offering great coverage to retain top talent. For a company to stay competitive in the years to come, it is crucial that it fully comprehends these options at their deepest level. Finance executives may be more receptive than their HR counterparts to new benefit approaches that take advantage of new structures and incentives created by health care reform. The Business Finance Magazine article points out:

“Historically, CEOs and presidents have made all decisions on human capital expenditures [such as health care], and while they often consult HR as part of that process, more often than not, CFOs are kept out of the loop. Giving CFOs a greater presence and voice in the process could help ensure that such important decisions are more fully vetted.”

Benefits plans are like any other aspect of the business: someone needs to be steering the ship to make sure it goes the right direction. My dad always said, “If the boat misses the harbor, rarely is it the harbor’s fault.” Benefits planning requires more than just setting a budget at the beginning of the year and relying on a human resources team to determine the specifics. The C-Suite has plans for managing every other aspect of the business—a strategic road map is necessary for benefits, too.

Remaining at the forefront

Our company works with senior executives every day to help them optimize their investments in employee benefits. In doing so, we see that, across industries, regions and business sizes, business leaders don’t have the most basic working knowledge about the new structures and incentives embedded in health care reform. Everything else is inconsequential until executives truly understand the implications of health care reform.

As we have been saying for several months, we believe health care reform is the single greatest opportunity in our lifetime to get employers to think differently about how they allocate compensation to benefit programs. The entity (whether a consultant or a carrier) that helps the C-suite with a health care reform response plan will have an excellent opportunity to prescribe a package of products and services to better meet the employer's needs (and escape the potential “trap” of fighting over the scraps left behind after major medical decisions are made).

Now is the time for employers to recognize and implement changes that will set them apart from their competition. The Towers article points out that "savvy organizations need to act now to responsibly assess the business implications, model different scenarios and consider the impact of each reform option on their entire reward program." Leading employers will not be the last to figure out the implications of health care reform. If they are, they will no longer be leading employers.

The CHROME Compass is the leading platform to facilitate this response plan. Certified CHROME Consultants are in the lead position to take advantage of the opportunities created by health care reform. But, as my Dad always says, “Eventually, even the dummies will figure it out.” There is a window of opportunity here. Let’s not miss it!


Eric Helman
CEO and Founder
ContinuousHealth
www.continuoushealth.com


This article was first featured in the March 13th edition of our e-newsletter, Directions. If you'd like to receive that weekly email, contact directions@continuoushealth.com. (Your email will never be shared, sold, or otherwise distributed, and you will receive only the type of content for which you sign up.)

Follow ContinuousHealth on LinkedIn or on Twitter @chealthupdate for interesting articles, industry insight, and a first look at new products and services.

Monday, May 21, 2012

Two Points of the Compass and How They’ll Transform Compensation Strategy


Our review of over 350 CHROME Compass analyses reveals that your average client’s plan is currently more affordable and covers more than health care reform will require. Let’s take a look at how employer-sponsored coverage will change as the result of these two points of the Compass.

3.63%


That is the percentage of adjusted gross household income that your client’s average employee contributes to his health premiums, based on the CHROME Compass analysis of 345 employer plans.

About three and a half percent, as opposed to the mandated nine and a half percent of modified adjusted gross household income that PPACA requires to make plans “affordable.”

80.52%


That is the average actuarial value of covered benefits for of all employer-sponsored plans, based on the CHROME Compass analysis.

Eighty percent, as opposed to the required sixty percent of actuarial value imposed by health care reform mandates in order for a plan to have “acceptable” coverage.

The Interplay of PPACA


Long term consequences


The new government standard allows higher contribution from employees than we’ve found on average by analyzing the plans of many of your client’s.  It also requires less coverage on an actuarial value basis than the averages we’ve found.  In fact, data generated with CHROME Compass, our leading predictive modeling tool, shows that 95.7% of employees are already in “affordable” coverage.

We’re on the brink of a major revolution in how businesses allocate compensation toward benefits.  Over the next few years, we’ll probably see a swing towards higher premium contributions from employees and a lower actuarial value of covered benefits as a result of two of the CHROME Compass points, the affordable cost and acceptable benefits requirements. The key will be the restructuring of compensation dollars in other areas to keep packages appealing to top talent.

With these significant changes only two plan renewals away, it is vital that your clients begin to reshape their business strategy in light of this massive legislation.  Let us partner with you as you navigate these changes with them.

For more information on how CHROME Compass identified these averages, reach out to your ContinuousHealth CHROME Compass Consultant.

This article was first featured in the February 28th edition of our newsletter. If you'd like to receive the weekly newsletter Directions, email directions@continuoushealth.com.  (Your email will never be shared, sold, or otherwise distributed, and you will receive only the type of content for which you sign up.)
Follow ContinuousHealth on LinkedIn or on Twitter @chealthupdate for interesting articles, industry insight, and a first look at new products and services.

Wednesday, October 12, 2011

The Jury’s In: Rate of Ineligible Dependents Increases with Health Care Reform

This post was originally published on the Employee Benefit Advisor's blog, Be Advised.

One of the first (and most popular) changes brought on by Health Care Reform was the mandatory extension of health plan eligibility to adult children up to age 26 regardless of student status or dependence upon the employee. Most people predicted that the rate of ineligible dependents would decrease after this provision took effect. Based upon a study my firm recently completed, comparing similar populations before and after the implementation of this provision, we can now conclusively state that the experts were wrong.

The rate of ineligible dependents on the health plans analyzed in this study has increased by approximately 1.5 percentage points. What caused this change? What do the results of dependent eligibility audits conducted after the passage of Health Care Reform tell us about employee behavior? What should employers do based upon the results of this study?

Health Care Reform Expectations
When Health Care Reform passed, many experts analyzed the data coming from dependent eligibility verification projects in order to predict the effect of Health Care Reform on the efficacy of these projects. Using our data as an example, prior to Health Care Reform in a sample set of over 113,000 dependents verified, 48% of the ineligible dependents were under age 20, and 29% of the ineligible dependents were over age 26. Correspondingly, 23% of the ineligible dependents were between the ages of 20 and 26 (the typical ages of full-time students). Further investigation showed that half of these ineligible dependents were ineligible because they failed the “relationship” test.

As a result, it seemed reasonable to assume that with the testing for full-time student status eliminated, 11.5% of the previously identified ineligible dependents would now pass eligibility verification. Said another way, if 6.5% of dependents were found to be ineligible prior to the passage of Health Care Reform, it was likely that the rate of ineligible dependents would be reduced by 11.5%. Based upon this hypothesis, experts expected the average rate of ineligible dependents post Health Care Reform to drop from 6.5% to 5.75%.

This reduction, while significant, would have only partially mitigated the strong business case for an employer to conduct a dependent eligibility audit. For some employers, however, who anticipated that they might fall at the lower end of the ranges of ineligible dependents, this 11.5% reduction may have been enough to discourage them from the project.

The Real Effects of Health Care Reform
In this most recent study, though, the opposite has proven true.  Using a statistically significant sample of recent projects conducted by ContinuousHealth, we’ve found that the average percentage of ineligible dependents has actually increased to 7.99% after implementation of the Affordable Care Act.  Additionally, it is interesting to note the percentage breakdown of the ineligible dependents by age demonstrates a shift in the ages of ineligible dependents. Specifically, 38% of the ineligible dependents identified in this sample set were under the age of 20, compared to 48% prior to Health Care Reform. The percentage between age 20 and age 26 is virtually unchanged at 23%. The percentage of ineligible dependents above age 26 increased from its pre-Health Care Reform levels of 29% to a post Health Care Reform 40%.

What Conclusions Can We Draw from Increased Ineligible Numbers?
Certainly there were other factors in place during the time period studied. Part of this shift could be a result of the continued softness in the employment environment. This not only affects the percentage of dual-earner households, but also contributes to the rate at which employees might attempt to have non-spouses or other adults added to their plan who lack access to coverage due to unemployment.

Additionally, in 70% or more of the employers, the only verification procedure for dependents prior to Health Care Reform was the verification of full-time student status conducted annually or biannually by the health care plan administrator. With the changes brought on by Health Care Reform, this verification process was no longer relevant, thus eliminating the only stopgap against ineligible dependents.

A Necessary Response
Regardless of the root causes for this increase in ineligible dependent rate, the call to action is clear. For years, it’s been clear that if employers are not making arrangements to verify dependent eligibility with a thorough process that includes both education and document verification, there are likely to be ineligible dependents on the plan gratuitously driving up the cost of health care. In the post Health Care Reform era where even more dependents are eligible, the exposure risk of covering ineligible dependents is more significant than ever.

If you’re interested in the details of this study, see also the case studies below.  For more information about Health Care Reform or dependent eligibility audits, follow ContinuousHealth and Eric Helman, CEO, on Twitter at @CHealthUpdate or visit www.continuoushealth.com. ContinuousHealth is an independent organization located in Atlanta, Georgia, that uses proprietary technology to help employers optimize their investments in employee benefits programs.  ContinuousHealth has performed over 300 dependent eligibility verification projects and distributes its products through an exclusive network of certified consultants and brokers.

Case Studies
Client A is a small company in transportation and manufacturing.  Anticipating the changes required after 9/23, Client A modified its policy into a non-grandfathered plan with extended child eligibility to 26 at their 9/1/2010 plan renewal, in advance of the PPACA requirement.  At the time of verification, the company had been following the Age 26 rule for four months.  As a small company that had already implemented the Health Care Reform changes, leadership expected to see low ineligible dependent numbers.  Instead, the Dependent Eligibility Verification found that 14.5% of dependents on the plan were ineligible.

Client B is a large retail chain with mostly white collar employees in a low-income tax bracket.  Its plan renewal was 2/1/11, and under its Ongoing Verification procedures, the company began verifying for the new Health Care Reform categories in mid-January.  Client B implemented a grandfathered policy with an Adult Child Exclusion policy:  if an adult child was eligible for coverage under his or her own employer’s policy, that dependent was not eligible for the policy of Client B.  Open Enrollment numbers showed a 20% increase of enrollees to the policy, which fit with its expectations for the 2011 year.  The biggest surprise, though, was the upswing of ineligibles:  during the original verification, between October 2009 and January 2010, the ContinuousHealth Dependent Eligibility Verification Audit found that 1,851, or 16.56%, of Client B’s 11,175 dependents enrolled were ineligible; during the first four months following the implementation of PPACA regulations, the ContinuousHealth ongoing dependent eligibility verification audit found 549, or 30.57%, of the 1,796 newly enrolled dependents to be ineligible for the new policy.  This number was nearly double the findings of the original project, when the eligibility criteria were more stringent.

Client C is a major automotive manufacturing company with a non-grandfathered plan and a February plan renewal.  The company began verifying for new categories in mid-February.  Prior to Health Care Reform provisions, the Dependent Eligibility Verification Audit identified 10.55% of enrolled dependents as ineligible.  After enacting the Age 26 requirement, as well as the non-residential requirement for stepchildren, the Ongoing Dependent Eligibility Verification found that 27.91% of new enrollees were ineligible.

Client D is a large hospital management system with 15 localized hospitals.  The management system did a Dependent Eligibility Verification Audit in 2010, prior to implementing Health Care Reform at their July 1, 2011 plan renewal, with 13 of its 15 hospitals. The two hospitals who did not participate initially were both located in Massachusetts and were excluded because they were covered under “RomneyCare,” a set of provisions that representatives of President Obama have cited as a model for PPACA[1] and which have been called an “ObamaCare preview.”[2] After the leadership team reviewed the results from the initial verification, the two hospitals in Massachusetts decided to undergo a ContinuousHealth Dependent Eligibility Verification Audit as well. The results were comparable with their non-Massachusetts counterparts:  the original verification found 10.1% ineligibles for hospitals that were not yet subject to PPACA; one Massachusetts hospital discovered that 6.34% of dependents were ineligible and the other found 9.64% of dependents were ineligible under the current plan guidelines.[3]


Client A
Client B
Client C
Client D
Industry
Transportation / Manufacturing
National Retail Chain
Automotive Manufacturing
Hospital Management System - 15 hospitals
# Dependents
350
11,000+
3,500
17,000+
Grandfathered or Non-Grandfathered
Non-grandfathered
Grandfathered: 
Adult Children eligible for own employers’ plan were ineligible
Non-grandfathered
2 Hospitals under “RomneyCare”
First Plan Renewal
9/1/2011, but implemented on 9/1/2010;
Age 26 compliant for 4 months at verification start
2/1/2011;
started verifying for HCR in mid-January
2/2011;
started verifying for HCR in mid-February
7/1/2011
Results
14.5% of dependents were ineligible, far higher than leadership expected
·  20% increase in Open Enrollment numbers

·  Original project in 2009-2010 found 16.56% of 11,175 dependents were ineligible

·  First 4 months of PPACA showed that 30.57% of the 1,796 newly enrolled were ineligible
·  Original DEVA found 10.55% of enrolled were ineligible

·  Post-HCR DEVA found 27.91% of new enrollees were ineligible

·  Initial project:  10.1% ineligibles

·  2 Hospitals excluded from initial verification because they were under RomneyCare. These did a DEVA after seeing other 13 hospitals’ results

·  Results were comparable: RomneyCare project:  6.34% ineligibles in one and 9.64% in the other
Financial Exposure Reduction
Over $184,960
·  Original project:  $4,995,000
·  First 4 months of PPACA: $1,482,300
·  Original project:  $1,114,345
·  First 4 months of PPACA: $1,500,442
Total savings:  $4,165,246



[1] Carol E. Lee, “White House Again Jabs Romney on Health Law,” Washington Wire, Wall Street Journal, http://blogs.wsj.com/washwire/2011/05/13/white-house-again-jabs-romney-on-health-law, (May 17, 2011).
[2] “National Health Preview:  RomneyCare’s bad outcomes keep coming,” Wall Street Journal, http://online.wsj.com/article/SB10001424052748703864204576313370527615288.html?KEYWORDS=national+health+preview+romneycare, (May 10, 2011).
[3] The hospitals from the original verification were also not doing document checks, while the two Massachusetts hospitals believed their employee document records were up to date, checking student status as well as IRS dependency, per their SPD.