Showing posts with label dependent verification. Show all posts
Showing posts with label dependent verification. Show all posts

Tuesday, July 31, 2012

Dependent Audit Case Studies, after PPACA

Client A is a small company in transportation and manufacturing.  Anticipating the changes required after 9/23, Client A modified its policy into a non-grandfathered plan with extended child eligibility to 26 at their 9/1/2010 plan renewal, in advance of the PPACA requirement.  At the time of verification, the company had been following the Age 26 rule for four months.  As a small company that had already implemented the health care reform changes, leadership expected to see low ineligible dependent numbers.  Instead, the Dependent Eligibility Verification found that 14.5% of dependents on the plan were ineligible.

Client B is a large retail chain with mostly white collar employees in a low-income tax bracket.  Its plan renewal was 2/1/11, and under its Ongoing Verification procedures, the company began verifying for the new health care reform categories in mid-January.  Client B implemented a grandfathered policy with an Adult Child Exclusion policy:  if an adult child was eligible for coverage under his or her own employer’s policy, that dependent was not eligible for the policy of Client B.  Open Enrollment numbers showed a 20% increase of enrollees to the policy, which fit with its expectations for the 2011 year. 

The big surprise, though, was the upswing of ineligibles:  during the original verification, between October 2009 and January 2010, the ContinuousHealth Dependent Eligibility Verification Audit found that 1,851, or 16.56%, of Client B’s 11,175 dependents enrolled were ineligible; during the first four months following the implementation of PPACA regulations, the ContinuousHealth ongoing dependent eligibility verification audit found 549, or 30.57%, of the 1,796 newly enrolled dependents to be ineligible for the new policy. This number was nearly double the findings of the original project, when the eligibility criteria were more stringent. Throughout the whole 2011 year, ineligible numbers came down, but were still considerably higher than the findings of the initial project, as between January and December 2011, ContinuousHealth identified that 26.84% of dependents did not meet the requirements to verify their eligibility for the plan. With the change in plan requirements under PPACA, Client B regularly found an increased rate of ineligibility by between ten and fourteen percent.

Client C is a major automotive manufacturing company with a non-grandfathered plan and a February plan renewal.  The company began verifying for new categories in mid-February.  Prior to health care reform provisions, the Dependent Eligibility Verification Audit identified 10.55% of enrolled dependents as ineligible. 

After enacting the Age 26 requirement and removing a residential requirement for stepchildren, the Ongoing Dependent Eligibility Verification found that 27.91% of new enrollees were ineligible during the first four months of PPACA.  For the 2011 year, Continuoushealth identified 24.1% of dependents on the plan were ineligible for coverage, a slight drop from the first few months.  Overall, Client C has found an increase of more than double the rate of ineligibles since PPACA.

Client D is a large hospital management system with 15 localized hospitals.  The management system did a Dependent Eligibility Verification Audit in 2010, prior to implementing health care reform at their July 1, 2011 plan renewal, with 13 of its 15 hospitals. The two hospitals who did not participate initially were both located in Massachusetts and were excluded because they were covered under “RomneyCare,” a set of provisions that representatives of President Obama have cited as a model for PPACA[1] and which have been called an “ObamaCare preview.”[2]

After the leadership team reviewed the results from the initial verification, the two hospitals in Massachusetts decided to undergo a ContinuousHealth Dependent Eligibility Verification Audit as well. The results were comparable with their non-Massachusetts counterparts:  the original verification found 10.1% ineligibles for hospitals that were not yet subject to PPACA; one Massachusetts hospital discovered that 6.34% of dependents were ineligible and the other found 9.64% of dependents were ineligible under the current plan guidelines.[3]

After the first plan renewal for the entire system under PPACA (7/1/2011), leadership requested that all hospitals undergo another dependent eligibility review.  The hospitals all had similar plan eligibility, all non-grandfathered with no spousal exclusions or surcharges. During that post-PPACA review in fall of 2011, ContinuousHealth identified 21.01% of the active dependents on the plan were unable to satisfy eligibility requirements. Specifically, the two hospitals in Massachusetts each found 10.29% and 16.19% ineligible during the second review. All hospitals saw an increase in ineligible dependents. The post-PPACA verification savings for Client D totaled more than $5 million in claims cost reduction. 

Client E is a national restaurant chain with hourly and salaried employees throughout the US. At the time of review, Client E had been following PPACA guidelines for 12 months. The Human Resources team systematically requested documentation for any new enrollees, but the client had not done full documentation verification. ContinuousHealth identified 6.08% of the plan participants were ineligible for coverage under the non-grandfathered plan guidelines. Ineligible dependents were primarily over the age of 18 years old and may have been added on the plan as “spouses” or “adult children,” though they were, in fact, unable to verify their eligibility as such.

 






Client A
Client B
Client C
Client D
Client E
Industry
Transportation / Manufacturing
National Retail Chain
Automotive Manufacturing
Hospital Management System - 15 hospitals
National Restaurant Chain
# Dependents
350
11,000+
3,500
17,000+
1,300
Grandfathered or Non-Grandfathered
Non-grandfathered
Grandfathered: 
Adult Children eligible for own employers’ plans were ineligible
Non-grandfathered
Non-Grandfathered;
2 Hospitals under “RomneyCare”
Non-Grandfathered
First Plan Renewal
9/1/2011, but implemented on 9/1/2010;
Age 26 compliant for 4 months at verification start
2/1/2011;
started verifying for HCR in mid-January
2/2011;
started verifying for HCR in mid-February
7/1/2011
1/1/2011
Results
14.5% of dependents were ineligible, far higher than leadership expected
·  20% increase in Open Enrollment numbers

·  Original project in 2009-2010 found 16.56% of 11,175 dependents were ineligible

·  First 4 months of PPACA showed that 30.57% of the 1,796 newly enrolled were ineligible

·  2011 showed that 26.84% of the 2,724 newly enrolled were ineligible
·  Original DEVA found 10.55% of enrolled were ineligible

·  Post-HCR DEVA found 27.91% of new enrollees were ineligible

·  2011 showed 24.1% of the 1,229 newly enrolled were ineligible

·  Initial project:  10.1% ineligibles

·  2 “Romneycare” hospitals excluded from initial verification did a DEVA after seeing other 13 hospitals’ results

·  Results were comparable: RomneyCare project:  6.34% ineligibles in one and 9.64% in the other

·  Post-PPACA found 21.01% ineligible overall
·  Identified 6.08% of active dependents were ineligible
Financial Exposure Reduction
Over $184,960
·  Original project:  $4,995,000
·  First 4 months of PPACA: $1,482,300
·  2011 verification: $1,462,000 (with a decrease in claims cost)
·  Original project:  $1,114,345

·  First 4 months of PPACA: $1,500,442

·  2011: $929,144
Total savings:  $4,165,246
Total savings:  $262,833


[1] Carol E. Lee, “White House Again Jabs Romney on Health Law,” Washington Wire, Wall Street Journal, http://blogs.wsj.com/washwire/2011/05/13/white-house-again-jabs-romney-on-health-law, (May 17, 2011).
[2] “National Health Preview:  RomneyCare’s bad outcomes keep coming,” Wall Street Journal, http://online.wsj.com/article/SB10001424052748703864204576313370527615288.html?KEYWORDS=national+health+preview+romneycare, (May 10, 2011).
[3] The hospitals from the original verification were also not doing document checks, while the two Massachusetts hospitals believed their employee document records were up to date, checking student status as well as IRS dependency, per their SPD.

Thursday, July 26, 2012

Fact or Fiction? Health Care Reform Eliminates the Need for Dependent Eligibility Verification

Last week, I was on the phone with one of our broker partners from the Midwest and he made a comment along the lines of “with health care reform, a lot of the appeal of dependent eligibility verification projects was taken away.” Well, at the risk of being argumentative, I shared with him the results of our post health care reform study* that showed, rather convincingly, that dependent verification projects are more valuable than ever.

Since that study was produced, our total number of audits conducted has grown to over 1,100. We have completed twice as many audits this year as last and the number of clients signing up for our Ongoing Dependent Eligibility Verification Services has risen above 70%. Moreover, we are now executing projects where the client has already conducted an internal audit (or used another firm) and are seeing significant savings. Dependent eligibility audits remain one of the only ways to take 3-5% out of health care expenses without any changes to the plan or contribution strategy. Brokers across the country are using this “weapon” as a way to win new business.
I think you owe it to yourself to do a top to bottom evaluation of your current book to be sure you have gotten them to seriously consider doing a project. And, if you are prospecting during this summer season, incorporate dependent eligibility verification into each sales presentation. Read on to review a reprise of our article on how the rate of ineligible dependents has increased from 6.5% to 7.99% with the passage of healthcare reform. 

*Report originally published on the Employee Benefit Advisor blog and November’s print issue of Employee Benefit Advisor magazine.

Rate of Ineligible Dependents Increases to 7.99% with health care reform


One of the first changes brought on by health care reform was the mandatory extension of health plan eligibility to adult children up to age 26 without regard to student status or other dependency upon the employee. Many experts predicted that the rate of ineligible dependents would decrease after this provision took effect and lower the effectiveness of Dependent Verification Projects.

Based upon a study my firm did in the fall comparing similar populations before and after the implementation of this provision, we can now conclusively state that the experts were wrong. The rate of ineligible dependents in the health plans analyzed in this study post health care reform has actually increased by approximately 1.5 percentage points.

Expectations prior to health care reform


When health care reform passed, many experts analyzed the data coming from dependent eligibility verification projects in order to predict the effect of health care reform on the efficacy of these projects. Using our data as an example, prior to health care reform in a sample set of over 113,000 dependents verified, 48% of the ineligible dependents were under age 20, 23% of the ineligible dependents were between the ages of 20 and 26 (the typical ages of full-time students), and 29% of the ineligible dependents were over age 26. Further investigation showed that half (11.5%) of ineligible dependents in the 20-26 age range were ineligible because they failed the “relationship” test. These wouldn’t be eligible for coverage regardless of their age.

It seemed reasonable to assume that with the dependent age limit increased to 26, about half of those who had been previously identified as ineligible dependents would now pass eligibility verification. The other half would still fail the relationship test and remain ineligible. Our own data led me to agree with the experts’ expectation of health care reform—that the average rate of ineligible dependents post health care reform would drop from 6.5% to 5.75% (a reduction of 11.5%).

That reduction, while significant, would have only partially mitigated the strong business case for an employer to conduct a dependent eligibility audit. There would be some employers, though, who anticipated falling at the lower end of the 5-12% average range of ineligible dependents. This 11.5% reduction may have been enough to discourage them from the project.

The real effects of health care reform


The fact is, our research since the passage of PPACA has proven that the opposite is true.  Using a statistically significant sample of recent audits conducted by ContinuousHealth, we’ve found that the average percentage of ineligible dependents has actually increased to 7.99% after implementation of the Affordable Care Act. 
A 19% increase!
Additionally, we’ve seen a shift in the ages of ineligible dependents. Our sample set had 10% fewer ineligibles under the age of 20 and about the same number of ineligibles between the age of 20 and 26. Ineligible dependents over the age of 26 grew by 11%.

What conclusions can we draw from increased ineligible numbers?


Certainly there were other factors in place during the time period studied.

Part of this shift could be a result of the continued softness in the employment environment. This affects the percentage of dual-earner households and contributes to the rate at which employees might attempt to have non-spouses or other adults added to their plan who lack access to coverage due to unemployment.

The publicity surrounding eligibility changes has been less than precise, even two years later. There is more potential that employees will attempt to enroll dependents that do not meet eligibility criteria. A person the employee calls “family” needs coverage (perhaps due to the softness of the market), and the employee therefore thinks he can cover them on “family” coverage.

With all of that, verification methods have been eradicated for most companies. For 70% or more of employers prior to health care reform, the only dependent verification procedure was full-time student status checks conducted annually or biannually by the health care plan administrator. PPACA’s changes eliminated the only stopgap against ineligible dependents.

A necessary response


Regardless of the root causes for this increase in ineligible dependent rate, I think the call to action is clear.

For years, we’ve seen that unless employers are making arrangements to verify dependent eligibility with a thorough process that includes both eligibility education and document verification, there are going to be ineligible dependents on every group plan, gratuitously driving up the cost of health care.

In fact, I’d say that the need is greater than ever to make sure ineligible dependents aren’t covered. The changes brought on by health care reform allow even more dependents to be eligible, so covering an ineligible dependent has a more significant exposure risk than ever.  With the prohibition on rescissions in PPACA, the financial exposure lands on the employer for ineligible dependents, since employers must prove employee fraud before exposure for high claims could be passed on.

I want your clients to be protected from the financial and compliance exposure of ineligible dependents, especially since that rate increased by 1.5% since implementing the provision. On top of all that, I’ll remind you again that dependent verification is a cost saving solution that regularly reduce plan expenses by 3-5% with no change in carriers or plan design. Our return on investment guarantee makes it a no-lose situation.  I think you owe it to yourself to do a top to bottom evaluation of your current book to be sure you have gotten them to seriously consider doing a project. And, if you are prospecting during this summer season, incorporate dependent eligibility verification into each sales presentation.

As you face a mid-market renewal season, propose a Dependent Verification Project with ContinuousHealth. It’ll be worth it.
If you’d like a copy of the original article or the case studies detailing report specifics, email directions@continuoushealth.com.




This article was first featured in the May 29th edition of our e-newsletter, Directions. If you'd like to receive that weekly email, contact directions@continuoushealth.com. (Your email will never be shared, sold, or otherwise distributed, and you will receive only the type of content for which you sign up.)

Follow ContinuousHealth on LinkedIn or on Twitter @chealthupdate for interesting articles, industry insight, and a first look at new products and services

Tuesday, July 10, 2012

Will Spousal Surcharges and Exclusions stick around after 2014?

You probably have clients who have researched implementing a spousal surcharge or exclusion. You may have some who have already done so for the 2011 or 2012 plan year. Spousal carve outs have grown exponentially over the past few years as an important way to offset rising health care costs. It’s likely that we’ll see them continue to grow in popularity… unless PPACA is interpreted as making them illegal. 

A debate arose in our office recently. Because we care about our partners, we have strong opinions about health care topics and how the PPACA legislation will play out for your clients. This time, the debate was about spousal exclusions and surcharges, and whether or not they’ll last after 2014. Our dependent audit team has seen a sharp escalation in the number of verifications for spousal exclusions and surcharges, which piqued the interest of our CHROME Compass consultants.

Spousal “carve out” is one way that employers are addressing the rising costs of health care coverage, and the trend is well documented, both in trade publications and the general media. In the fall, the Society for Human Resource Management featured an article on the renewed interest in the “working spouse” provision. The CNN Money blog had a post about it this time last year as provision on 2012 plans that employees should get used to seeing. Entrepreneur magazine outlined spousal exclusion as a good option to keep the rest of the benefits plan robust.

Most commentators note that excluding or mandating a surcharge for working spouses with other access is not going to be good for every company. As you know from working with your clients, each employer is different, and plan specifications must be carefully crafted to best serve the company’s needs. Companies need to have a plan for verifying working spouses before implementing the provision. Articles rightly advise that employers need to question if savings will counter additional administrative burden or business disruption.

So, while many are discussing the rising popularity and what types of companies could benefit from it, few people seem to be talking about the potential legality of spousal carve out or how long the provision will be permitted to last after 2014. That was the subject of our office debate this week.

Some members of our team believe that an explicit interpretation of PPACA disallows spousal exclusion. PPACA requires that coverage is offered to employees and their dependents… regardless of access elsewhere. The intent of the law appears to end spousal exclusion entirely, and when the health care reform law comes into full effect in 2014, spousal exclusions may be penalized or eliminated. Additionally, while working spouse provisions are ERISA-compliant and legal under most federal laws, they may not be compliant with state marital discrimination laws.

Another faction in our office points out that legislative intent does not necessary mandate how the final law is interpreted and how it will play out in reality. Legal contests don’t always make provisions like this go away, and, even if the legislative intent is clear, loopholes are guaranteed. To date, the mechanism for penalty if an employer excludes spouses with access to other coverage is yet undetermined. We first assumed that there may be a $2000 or $3000 penalty for exclusion, following the tradition of the other penalties built into PPACA. That is not yet outlined, so, if anything, it’s becoming more possible that this provision would fall under nondiscrimination testing.

Surcharges, as opposed to exclusions, seem to have a stronger argument under PPACA, although there still is not enough guidance to confidently answer either one. Studies show that $600-$1,200 in annual charges for spouses with access elsewhere, on top of premium costs, may incentivize spouses to engage their own employers’ plans. As a bonus, those who remain on the plan contribute increased premium revenue.

Our debate wasn’t officially resolved, but these are the questions we’re bringing to our partners and our clients. Where do you stand on these cost reduction strategies for your clients’ next plan year? If you’re recommending a spousal exclusion or surcharge, how are you verifying them?










This article was first featured in the April 24th edition of our e-newsletter, Directions. If you'd like to receive that weekly email, contact directions@continuoushealth.com. (Your email will never be shared, sold, or otherwise distributed, and you will receive only the type of content for which you sign up.)

Follow ContinuousHealth on LinkedIn or on Twitter @chealthupdate for interesting articles, industry insight, and a first look at new products and services.

Wednesday, June 27, 2012

It may be accessible, but is it useful?

The engagement of internet-accessible employee benefits tools continues to grow exponentially. Some firms have begun touting “web only” solutions as a viable alternative to more traditional approaches to employee engagement. As a leading provider of technology solutions for group benefit needs and with all the interest in online enrollment and HR administration tools, we thought it would be interesting to research how accessible web-based platforms really are for employees.  How much are your clients (and their employees) really using these platforms? Is the focus on web-based tools truly driving efficiency or is it also creating barriers for employees who have low levels of comfort with and access to technology? ContinuousHealth recently tracked employee and employer login data for our entire employee benefits technology suite of systems. Prior to pulling the data, we had certain predispositions about the results: As a technology company, we know that not everyone is comfortable working with software that they do not use regularly.  We refer to these types of systems as “single transaction platforms.” For these types of systems, we assumed employee web access would be fairly low, and employer access would be moderate to high. While we are proud of our systems, we realize many of our clients never walk through the technology, but those who do find it helpful and, in the words of one consultant, “slick.” But what is the real level of web access to our systems?  Who is really logging in, and how can we make our products better, knowing those results?

As we began to review the data across the several platforms we offer, using the employee and employer access from your clients’ projects, the results surprised us. First of all, let us be clear, ContinuousHealth has always been of the mindset that “all access” is achieved (like a brand marketing campaign) by using nearly every available medium and mode to reach employees. For both compliance and effectiveness reasons, HR applications can’t settle for 80% response rates. For us, web access has always been an “and” option as opposed to an “or” option. Having said that, let’s look at web access across a variety of platforms and needs.  

Employees and internet accessibility


We first took a look at employee access of our benefits administration platform, individual insurance coverage system and our dependent verification technology. Across all client platforms, we show fairly low levels of access by employees.

Only 17% of the employees going through dependent audits log into the website, and just 5% actually upload documents to the portal to move forward in completing the process. You may have heard of dependent audit companies that advertise a web-only verification. They state that “98% of people have access to the internet.” That may be true of companies with a predominantly white collar workforce, but we find that, even among that population, most people don’t have the ability to turn a hard copy document, such as a marriage certificate, into a soft copy document. Our employee login data shows that internet access is still not the best way to identify ineligible dependents with minimal business disruption - especially if you want to reach high penetration rates. By offering an all-access platform, we typically see response rates in the 97-98% range. Achieving this consistently with a web only solution is next to impossible without a high degree of HR involvement.

In our benefits administration and individual coverage technology, 39% of all system logins are employees logging in to enroll or complete surveys for assistance with individual medical insurance. This is a good bit higher than we predicted, and it’s an argument toward the need for online enrollment options. 3-5% of all errors in enrollment are caused by manual keying in of enrollment requests, and this can be reduced by allowing employees access to the system.  The fairly high number of employee logins shows that online enrollment is accessible and a highly utilized option, viable for moving most companies to either an online employee or enroller-assisted option.

Employers and internet accessibility


The data showed, though that most vital is employer accessibility to technology.

For our benefits administration and individual coverage technologies, we found that 46% of all logins were employers logging in. This includes assisting employees with the technology, reviewing enrollment, and viewing statistics. The number is much higher than expected.

Employers also have access to our dependent verification technology, a system that we pride ourselves in for our intentional user-friendly, “single transaction” technology. We recognize that employers may not be logging in every day, so the system shouldn’t be software that you must learn. Instead, it should be user-friendly enough that employers can understand the first time logging in. That said, although we built our system with ease of access in mind, we were still surprised to see how many of our employers, your clients, are accessing it—80% of the employers who are going through dependent audits with us have logged in to the website, either to review statistics or download reports.

The details


Substantial money invested in giving employees access to web applications for human resources administration will only pay out if employees really do utilize these systems. Employees should receive non-web based communications and resources in addition to any internet access. Any time you’re trying to get employees to do just one thing, in this case provide documents or manage benefits, you have to offer options beyond online accessibility.

Enroller-assisted online portals are good options, and crucial to the success of human resources technology is quality access for employers. As employers manage their employees, for large and small companies alike, it is vital that the employer feels connected to the data, and, thus, to their employees.

For your clients


Rest assured – options that are exclusively manual and paper-based are bad. There are too many employees with access to the web to be tied down to old ways of doing business. But when you evaluate new approaches, keep an eye on reaching everyone.  

You know better than we do what your clients need, but these are the important questions to ask, and important adoption data to know, as you consider the next steps as their advisor.




This article was first featured in the April 10th edition of our e-newsletter, Directions. If you'd like to receive that weekly email, contact directions@continuoushealth.com. (Your email will never be shared, sold, or otherwise distributed, and you will receive only the type of content for which you sign up.)

Follow ContinuousHealth on LinkedIn or on Twitter @chealthupdate for interesting articles, industry insight, and a first look at new products and services.

Monday, June 11, 2012

All Dependent Eligibility Audits Are Not Created Equal

Response Rate is Crucial


As employers seek out money saving options in their health care plans, dependent eligibility verification audits have grown in popularity. Recent national studies show that 74% percent of employers plan to do a dependent audit in 2012, up from 69% in 2011. And there’s good reason to do so:  the 10-14 week process identifies bottom-line savings of 3-5% of annual health expenses without changes to carrier or plan design. 

More often than not, employers contract with third party companies in order to ensure that the audits run smoothly and securely, since verification is typically too time-consuming to do in-house. All dependent eligibility audits, however, are not created equal.  

As the Director of Operations for dependent audit at ContinuousHealth, I can tell you that horror stories abound. Clients often come to us saying that they attempted a project internally and overwhelmed their understaffed Human Resources department. Other clients say they used a third party and their Human Resources department was still bombarded because the communications weren’t clear. They cite experiences from other firms saying that employees were treated like criminals when they truly didn’t understand what constituted a dependent.

And, overwhelmingly, we hear about companies that drag verification on for months but still can’t get as much as 30% of the population to comply.

As Eric always says, “If the ship misses the harbor, rarely is it the harbor’s fault.” High response rates are a critical success factor for dependent audits. A dependent verification is not rocket science.* It should be based on a solid employee approach, one that educates and assists employees to complete, with multiple access points (mail, web, fax, phone and email) and hard-to-ignore communications. There needs to be consistent coordination between HR and a dedicated audit Account Manager, with the ability for the employer to track real time statistics. And above all, the external communication and contact with the employee must be such that response rates are driven into the 90% range.  The only thing that’s going to give your client credibility at the end of this is that the project was very, very thorough.

When we began doing these projects in 2008, at the request of one of our other advisor partners, we found 3 root causes of ineligibles:  lack of awareness of what constitutes a dependent (on family coverage; call this person “family”), timing (recently or not-so-recently divorced), and fraud.  We made a conscious decision to approach each employee as though his ineligible dependents are the result of a lack of awareness. This “Compassionate Compliance” approach has evolved into the leading method for high response/low disruption projects. In a project where the issue is a lack of awareness of the definition of a dependent, can you really trust the results if 10-20% of your population doesn’t respond?  The entire integrity of the project is compromised.  We’ve had clients who said that if fewer than 90% responded, they wouldn’t even drop the self-identified ineligibles. 

A dependent audit should not be an exercise in kicking undereducated or lazy people off the plan. If you do it right, you should be getting a 97% response rate consistently. We recently had a client finish the project in 8 weeks with a 99% response rate, another in 14 weeks with 100% (both had savings higher than a 3:1 return on investment). These results are feasible with the right audit company. 

It’s possible to design an audit where you find 20% ineligible, but we don’t think that’s the goal of most employers. When we initially designed our audit, we approached it with a marketing mindset: what does it take to get everyone to respond? Our job is to do the most thorough project we can, generating maximum compliance and minimal business disruption. We never want anyone to lose coverage because they were unaware of the verification.

Our company was one of the first to market with this product. We offer the industry’s leading response rate as well as the highest return on investment guarantee. If you’re like most of our consultant partners, you’re suggesting a dependent audit or ongoing eligibility maintenance to your clients this year.  There is a difference in the firm you choose and the approach they take. We would be honored if you would choose ContinuousHealth.

Kelly Hudson
Director of Operations
ContinuousHealth, LLC
http://www.continuoushealth.com




This article was first featured in the March 20th edition of our e-newsletter, Directions. If you'd like to receive that weekly email, contact directions@continuoushealth.com. (Your email will never be shared, sold, or otherwise distributed, and you will receive only the type of content for which you sign up.)

Follow ContinuousHealth on LinkedIn or on Twitter @chealthupdate for interesting articles, industry insight, and a first look at new products and services.

Tuesday, July 19, 2011

Early Results are In: HCR may increase the Number of Ineligible Dependents

Originally published at Executive Street, a Vistage International blog.
While Health Care Reform is currently a much-discussed item in the media, the Wall Street Journal recently reported that the majority of CFOs are not considering the repercussions for their companies. The following study proves the fiscal responsibility for corporate leadership to research the effects of the Patient Protection and Affordable Care Act (PPACA) on their health care plans.

Ineligible Dependents:  Previously 5-12% of Dependents on Group Health Care Plans
Many experts believe that the number of ineligible dependents on a company’s health care plan will decrease as the mandates of the PPACA take effect. Nationwide, prior to PPACA, between 5-12% of group plan participants were typically found to be ineligible. The early results are in for a study showing that wider eligibility criteria may, in fact, directly correlate to higher percentages of ineligible dependents. 

Reform guidelines now require that adult children up to the age of 26 be eligible for coverage on their parents’ group health care plans, regardless of marital or employment status.* Many employers assume that this will significantly increase their enrollment body, and recent news reports confirm.  The enrollment of this age group is even higher than expected, as many as 600,000 new dependents in the first year alone.

Relatedly, many employers believe that investigating ineligibles is no longer necessary. Full-time student verification of that age group was standard practice with most group health care providers, and with this demographic now under mandated coverage, why check at all?

The Effects of Health Care Reform
Statistics gathered from recently conducted dependent eligibility verification audits show the need still exists and is, in fact, greater than ever. Projects completed since the implementation of Health Care Reform guidelines show nearly double the number of ineligible dependents. The average number of ineligible dependents identified on group coverage has risen from 8% to over 15%. 

The same ineligible dependents who existed prior to 9/23/10, excepting non-students, are still attempting to gain coverage from group plans. Dependents typically found who are not eligible for most plans include:
Ø  former spouses,
Ø  non-spouses,
Ø  former stepchildren,
Ø  grandchildren,
Ø  grandchildren over the age of 18 who are not enrolled in school,
Ø  non-child blood relatives and
Ø  non-eligible dependents declared on tax returns. 
Additionally, Health Care Reform has created new potentially ineligible dependent types, namely spouses and adult children who have coverage on other plans.

Prior to Reform, approximately 24% of ineligible dependents fell into the age range of 19-26. Of that 24%, half are unable to prove relationship. Thus, only 12% of typical ineligible dependents were previously non-students and are likely to qualify for coverage as a result of the change in age requirements. To put that into perspective, if a hypothetical employer covers 1,250 dependents and falls in the middle ground of 8% ineligible, 100 dependents would exit the plan. Health Care Reform guidelines for adult children now make 12 of those eligible. The other 88 remain ineligible and underscore the importance of continuing to verify dependent eligibility in a post-Health Care Reform nation. 

While the wider eligibility guidelines of PPACA do result in more dependents on a plan, the instance of and the exposure risk associated with ineligible dependents has not decreased. Rather, early results show that Health Care Reform directly correlates with higher percentages of ineligible dependents and, thus, an increased fiscal responsibility for CEOs and CFOs to recognize and eliminate fraud.

Case Study Results from Recent Dependent Eligibility Verification Audits:

Client A
Client B
Client C
Client D
Industry
Transportation / Manufacturing
National Retail Chain
Automotive Manufacturing
Hospital Management System - 15 hospitals
# Dependents
350
11,000+
3,500
17,000+
Grandfathered or Non-Grandfathered
Non-grandfathered
Grandfathered: 
Adult Children eligible for own employers’ plan were ineligible
Non-grandfathered
TBD;
2 Hospitals under “RomneyCare”
First Plan Renewal
9/1/2011, but implemented on 9/1/2010;
Age 26 compliant for 4 months at verification start
2/1/2011;
started verifying for HCR in mid-January
2/2011;
started verifying for HCR in mid-February
7/1/2011
Results
14.5% of dependents were ineligible, far higher than leadership expected
·  20% increase in Open Enrollment numbers

·  Original project in 2009-2010 found 16.56% of 11,175 dependents were ineligible

·  First 4 months of PPACA showed that 30.57% of the 1,796 newly enrolled were ineligible
·  Original DEVA found 10.55% of enrolled were ineligible

·  Post-HCR DEVA found 27.91% of new enrollees were ineligible

·  Initial project:  10.1% ineligibles

·  2 Hospitals excluded from initial verification because they were under RomneyCare. These did a DEVA after seeing other 13 hospitals’ results

·  Results were comparable: RomneyCare project:  6.34% ineligibles in one and 9.64% in the other
Financial Exposure Reduction
Over $184,960
·  Original project:  $4,995,000
·  First 4 months of PPACA: $1,482,300
·  Original project:  $1,114,345
·  First 4 months of PPACA: $1,500,442
Total savings:  $4,165,246

A White Paper detailing final results will be available after all members of the study have been subject to PPACA regulations for six months or more. For more information about Health Care Reform or Dependent Eligibility Verification Audits, reach out to Vistage member Eric Helman, CEO of ContinuousHealth, at ehelman@continuoushealth.com, or visit www.continuoushealth.com. ContinuousHealth is an independent organization located in Atlanta Georgia that uses proprietary technology to help employers optimize their investments in employee benefits programs.  ContinuousHealth has performed over 250 Dependent Eligibility Verification projects. ContinuousHealth distributes its products through an exclusive network of certified Brokers and Consultants.